OKLAHOMA CITY (AP) – Oklahoma Gov. Kevin Stitt’s ongoing feud with most of the Native American tribes within the state has grown so contentious that fellow Republicans within the Legislature and the state’s legal professional common are contemplating pushing him out of tribal negotiations altogether.
Those agreements, referred to as compacts, have been labored out between the state and tribes during the last couple of a long time to divvy up income from playing, automobile tags and the sale of tobacco and motor gas on tribal land, all of which offer main income streams into state and tribal coffers.
Tribal casinos alone paid practically $200 million to the state final yr underneath agreements giving tribes the unique proper to supply on line casino playing.
State Republican leaders are grumbling publicly that Stitt’s hostile posture towards the tribes, together with vetoing the extension of some compacts, are costing extra than simply cash. They say it’s additionally eroding the connection with tribal leaders that, though typically testy, has been nurtured for many years throughout Republican and Democratic administrations.
“Even (former) President Trump has mentioned he doesn’t know why the governor has such animosity toward the tribes,” stated Senate President Pro Tempore Greg Treat, an Oklahoma City Republican. “It’s nonsensical.”
Stitt’s relationship with many tribal leaders has deteriorated since he unsuccessfully tried to transform playing contracts by renegotiating the state’s share of on line casino income early in his first time period. Many of the state’s strongest tribes tried to make use of their political affect final yr to stop Stitt from profitable a second time period.
This yr, Stitt, himself a citizen of the Cherokee Nation, responded by vetoing just about each legislative measure endorsed by the tribes, together with a invoice that might have allowed Native American college students to put on tribal regalia at commencement ceremonies.
Stitt says he’s making an attempt to barter one of the best deal for the entire state’s greater than 4 million residents, notably with regards to the tobacco compacts.
Stitt is anxious that until the compacts are renegotiated, the U.S. Supreme Court’s landmark McGirt choice on tribal sovereignty, which decided a big swathe of jap Oklahoma stays a Native American reservation, may enable tribes to undercut non-tribal retailers throughout that space.
Under the present compacts, tribal tobacco gross sales are restricted to retail places on tribal belief land, however because the McGirt choice, courts have decided greater than 40% of the state is now throughout the boundaries of historic reservations.
The feud between Stitt and the tribes has now spilled into the Republican-controlled Legislature, which is scheduled to satisfy in a particular session Monday simply to override Stitt’s vetoes of payments that might prolong tribal compacts on tobacco and motor automobiles for one more yr.
Treat stated he’s prepared to present the governor one other yr to barter with the tribes “in good faith,” however that if no progress is proven the Legislature may take over the precise to barter the compacts. Although the governor’s workplace traditionally has dealt with compact negotiations with tribes, Treat stated state legislation additionally authorizes the Legislature to take action.
Oklahoma’s Republican Attorney General Gentner Drummond additionally has been important of Stitt’s posturing in opposition to the tribes and urged the Legislature to let him assume the protection of Oklahoma’s curiosity in an ongoing authorized struggle over playing compacts involving the governor’s workplace and Cherokee Nation.
“Oklahoma’s relationship with our tribal nations has suffered greatly as a result of the governor’s divisive rhetoric and ceaseless legal attacks,” Drummond stated.
Five of Oklahoma’s strongest tribes – the Cherokee, Chickasaw, Choctaw, Muscogee (Creek) and Seminole nations – issued a joint decision final week accusing the governor of not negotiating in good religion and threatening “to undo decades of work and damage tribal-state cooperation for generations to come.” Stitt disputes he’s not negotiating in good religion.
Feuds between governors and Native American tribes usually are not distinctive to Oklahoma.
Republican legislative leaders in Arizona in 2020 threatened to stop tribes from renewing playing licenses, a important funding supply for a lot of tribes, if they’d unresolved disputes over water rights.
In Connecticut, throughout the top of the pandemic, the state’s governor engaged in a uncommon dispute with its two federally acknowledged tribes, the Mohegan Tribe and Mashantucket Pequot Tribal Nation, over the tribes’ choice to reopen their large casinos.
But in Oklahoma, the place the tribes are vitally vital to the economic system, notably in depressed rural areas, even fellow Republicans are scratching their heads at Stitt’s continued hostility towards the tribes.
Treat described Stitt’s 2021 alternative to not renew tribal compacts over searching and fishing a “stupid decision” that has value the state $35 million. Stitt’s workplace stated on the time the compacts have been unfair as a result of tribal residents may buy licenses at a less expensive price.
The variety of licensed hunters and anglers in Oklahoma, which is used to calculate federal funds for wildlife conservation, has been diminished as a result of many Native Americans have chosen to acquire licenses from the tribes, which now not have an settlement to remit funds to the state.
The governor’s considerations in regards to the fallout from the McGirt Supreme Court choice have been heightened final month when a federal appeals court docket decided town of Tulsa had no authority to problem a rushing ticket to a Choctaw citizen.
“Citizens of Tulsa, if your city government cannot enforce something as simple as a traffic violation, there will be no rule of law in eastern Oklahoma,” Stitt stated.
Stitt’s argument a few cascading impact of the McGirt choice has benefit. Already, 1000’s of Native American taxpayers in Oklahoma have claimed an exemption from paying state revenue tax underneath laws governing taxation of tribal residents in “Indian Country.”
An Okmulgee girl and Muscogee (Creek) citizen, Alicia Stroble, claims she is exempt from paying state revenue tax in a case pending earlier than the Oklahoma Supreme Court. Several tribes have filed “friend of the court” briefs siding with Stroble’s place.
“It’s not going to work,” Stitt stated. “We can’t have two different systems.”
While many tribal sovereignty points stay unresolved following the McGirt choice, specialists on tribal legislation say the answer may be discovered by working with the tribes slightly than preventing them in court docket.
“There has to be a way for us to work together, and that tends to be the answer to almost all the questions,” stated Sara Hill, legal professional common for the Cherokee Nation. “The alternatives are always painful, expensive litigation.”
___
Associated Press reporters Felicia Fonseca in Arizona and Susan Haigh in Connecticut contributed to this report.
Content Source: www.washingtontimes.com