Tuesday, October 22

What a Distinction Ten Days Can Make as Postseason Odds Shift and Swing

Dylan Moore
Stephen Brashear-USA TODAY Sports

After a frantic commerce deadline with an extra of patrons, a number of dedicated sellers fielding affords, and a handful of in-betweeners on the cusp of competition, the month of August is doing its finest to separate the actual contenders from the remainder. Ten days in, 5 groups — the Angels, Yankees, Guardians, Reds and Diamondbacks — have seen their playoff probabilities slashed by greater than half, and a sixth (the Red Sox) has gone from 24.6% to 13.8%. Meanwhile, the Rangers responded to a late-July skid with an eight-game successful streak, the Cubs doubled their playoff odds with sequence wins over the Reds and Braves, the Phillies performed their method into the highest Wild Card spot within the National League, and the Mariners swept the Angels and Padres to leapfrog New York, Boston, and Los Angeles within the AL Wild Card race. It’s been fairly the shuffle for a ten-day stretch.

Biggest Changes in Playoff Odds in August

Team Entering August Today Change
Cubs 24.50% 50.40% 25.90%
Phillies 66.30% 87.90% 21.60%
Mariners 18.80% 39.40% 20.60%
Twins 70.70% 85.90% 15.20%
Rangers 75.00% 87.80% 12.80%
Giants 60.90% 72.90% 12.00%
Brewers 65.40% 75.90% 10.50%
Mets 11.90% 1.70% -10.20%
Red Sox 24.60% 13.80% -10.80%
Yankees 23.10% 9.00% -14.10%
Guardians 27.80% 12.30% -15.50%
Angels 19.50% 2.40% -17.10%
Reds 46.20% 20.90% -25.30%
Diamondbacks 47.70% 17.00% -30.70%

Some of the early-August woes have been notably dramatic in vogue. The Angels made a valiant resolution to go all in on the ultimate season of Shohei Ohtani’s contract, however regardless of including Lucas Giolito, C.J. Cron and Randal Grichuk, a seven-game dropping streak dropped their playoff odds from 19.5% to a bleak 1.4% (they’ve since recouped all of 1 proportion level with a pair of wins in opposition to the Giants).

The different contender for the AL’s most pissed off clubhouse thus far this month: the Yankees, who went with a delicate purchase on the commerce deadline. Things acquired even worse days after the deadline, first with Domingo Germán leaving the membership for “inpatient treatment for alcohol abuse,” after which Anthony Rizzo occurring the injured record with signs of a “likely concussion” attributed to a collision that occurred over two months earlier. Despite all this, the Yankees managed a sequence cut up with the Astros at residence, however latest sequence losses to the Orioles, Rays and White Sox have continued a freefall that began within the absence of Aaron Judge in June and July, dipping their playoff odds underneath 10%.

Things usually are not trying a lot brighter in Boston. The Red Sox performed a few of the league’s finest baseball in July, simply in time to persuade Chaim Bloom and his workers to hold on to a few of the expertise that may have enticed patrons on the deadline. But regardless of a sequence win over the Royals this week, the Red Sox at the moment are 4–8 of their final 12, together with an important sweep by the hands of the Blue Jays at residence final weekend. Frustrations have boiled over into the clubhouse, as properly, with Alex Verdugo incomes his second benching of the season from Alex Cora after apparently arriving later than anticipated to Saturday’s sport, prompting Cora to name Saturday “one of his worst days” with the Red Sox. Now they don’t have anything to point out for his or her excellent month; at 4 video games again from the third wild card, they’re additional out of a playoff spot than they have been initially of July.

Then there’s Cleveland, the place the Guardians have received as many brawls as they did video games within the first week of August. Despite being only a sport behind the Twins for the AL Central lead, they opted to promote on the deadline, transferring Aaron Civale, Josh Bell, and Amed Rosario. Unsurprisingly, they’ve gone 3–6 to begin August because of an anemic offensive effort, failing to attain greater than 5 runs in a sport in two weeks. The stretch was lowlighted by baseball’s most explosive on-field battle of 2023 throughout Saturday’s loss to the White Sox, which resulted in suspensions and fines for José Ramírez, Emmanuel Clase, Terry Francona, and third base coach Mike Sarbaugh. Their playoff odds have dwindled from 27.8% to 12.3%.

These American League meltdowns have labored out properly particularly for the Mariners, who’ve helped themselves with sequence wins over the Red Sox and Angels and a seven-game successful streak powered by glorious pitching. They’ve allowed three or fewer runs in six of these seven wins, posting a 2.96 ERA, 3.47 FIP and three.62 xFIP to begin the month with a .254 wOBA in opposition to, the second lowest within the majors. With Los Angeles, New York, Boston, and Cleveland trending down, Seattle now has the higher hand among the many groups on the surface trying in. The Twins, too, have benefitted particularly from Cleveland’s stumbling, and thanks largely to the occasions of the final 10 days, have a cushty 85.9% probability of taking the AL Central.

In the National League, the collapses of the Diamondbacks, Reds, and Marlins have been dramatic in scale, if much less so off the sector. Arizona was probably the greatest groups in baseball within the first half, separated from the Dodgers for the NL West lead solely by proportion factors. In the second half, the D-Backs have been the worst group in baseball at 5–19, together with an 0–8 begin to August after an lively deadline that introduced in Paul Sewald, Tommy Pham, and Jace Peterson. They’re experiencing considerably of a reversal in run-differential luck; after going 57–50 with a run differential of zero by means of July, seven of their eight losses in August have come by one or two runs.

The story is similar in Miami and Cincinnati. The Marlins and Reds had the fourth- and eighth-best information in baseball within the first half, respectively, regardless of each having damaging run differentials. But after staying comparatively quiet on the deadline, the Reds have gone 1–8 in August, not solely dropping their division lead but in addition falling out of playoff place altogether. Meanwhile, the one factor protecting the Marlins within the third Wild Card spot (and with comparably excessive 41.1% playoff odds as of now) is that the Diamondbacks and Reds have been worse.

National League Collapses

Team First-Half W-L First-Half W% First-Half Rank Second-Half W-L Second-Half W% Second-Half Rank August W-L August W% August Rank
Diamondbacks 52-39 .571 T-6 5-19 .208 30 0-8 .000 30
Reds 50-41 .549 T-8 10-16 .385 26 1-8 .111 29
Marlins 53-39 .576 4 7-17 .292 29 3-6 .333 T-24

All this floundering has been to the advantage of the Phillies, Giants, and Brewers, who’ve every loved playoff odds bumps of 10 or extra proportion factors within the final 10 days with out having to play all that properly. The Cubs have continued a sizzling second half with a 6–3 begin to August, eclipsing the 50% playoff odds threshold for the primary time all season this week after hitting a season low of 6.3% simply three weeks in the past on July 20.

All informed, within the first 10 days of August, 14 groups have seen their playoff odds shift by double digits in a single path or the opposite. It’s been a remarkably streaky stretch of pennant-race baseball throughout the league.

August Streaks of 5+ Games

Team W/L Length Dates
Rangers W 8 8/1–8/8
Mariners W 7 8/2–
Twins W 5 8/3–8/7
Dodgers W 5 8/6–
Diamondbacks L 8 8/1–
Angels L 7 8/1–8/7
Reds L 6 8/1–8/6
Mets L 6 8/1–8/6
Marlins L 5 8/3-8/7

SOURCE: Baseball-Reference

If all of this could occur in 10 days, the following 10 may deliver simply as a lot reshuffling and chaos. There are nonetheless greater than seven weeks left within the regular-season schedule, and if the Cubs could make that form of progress in three weeks, there’s nonetheless hope for individuals who have had catastrophic begins to August. And if Arizona and Miami can fall so far as they’ve, it’s no positive factor that August’s early winners will proceed their momentum.

Content Source: blogs.fangraphs.com